Portal, AZ - Rodeo, NM

Chiricahua Regional Council

What’s New?

This short update reviews the recent activities of the Chiricahua Regional Council. Please feel free to forward it to friends and colleagues.

The monsoons have continued at great levels this year with some areas receiving over five inches of rain just in July. It’s one of the wettest monsoons we’ve seen in years!


CRC’s Stewardship program has continued to be busy working with the Coronado National Forest in the Chiricahuas to replace damaged, missing or inaccurate trail signs. The CNF has purchased the equipment and materials for this to happen, and we are making the signs. 
















CRC’s Stewardship program has welcomed Wild Arizona’s Youth Conservation Corps, who have been working on local projects including Burro Trail, a new Interpretive Trail linking the Visitor Information Center with Silver Peak Trail, new rock steps at lower Silver Peak, and the Nature Trail at Sunny Flat. More information is available here.


CRC has been celebrating 30 years of great work, and we’ve assembled a list of the highlights here. There is much to be proud of, and we are grateful to members like you. We also hosted a webinar this spring to talk about our work, and an archive of that is available here

As an update on the US Air Force proposal to increase military training in our area, due to public pressure, the deadline for scoping comments was extended into early June. Also during that time, the number of signatures on the online petition exceeded 1200. Thank you! With your support, Peaceful Chiricahua Skies has also sent information packets to many elected officials, as well as public agencies who will be involved in the next steps. Currently, the Air Force is preparing the Draft EIS, which is planned to be released in the fall of 2023. After that there will be a public review and comment period, the Final EIS (summer 2024), and the Record of Decision (fall 2024). We will remain diligent on this as it moves forward.

Lastly, the original signed Congressional Act that protects Cave Creek Canyon from development was recently rediscovered after having been missing for some time. You can read more about this here. We hope to have this document preserved and displayed for the public soon.

WHAT WE DO

Chiricahua Regional Council


The CRC works on issues affecting the Chiricahua and Peloncillo region and focuses on maintaining healthy, intact habitats. We disseminate information about potential threats to the region, as those threats arise. We advocate careful land stewardship and seek to educate the public, as needed, on any aspect of natural history, conservation and land use, including sound grazing practices. Diverse interests from the community––from biologists to ranchers––are represented on our Board of Directors.


PRESIDENT:  Wynne Brown

Vice President:  Noel Snyder
Secretary: Michele Lanan

Treasurer: Eskild Petersen


BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Josiah Austin

Narca Moore-Craig

David Hodges

Helen Snyder

Dirk Sigleer




MEMBERSHIP

A 2-year membership costs $20. When issues arise affecting the Chiricahua-Peloncillo-Dragoon region, we inform our membership of the problem and recommend actions to remedy the situation. These notices come at irregular (and, thankfully, infrequent) intervals––however, when action has been needed, our members have risen to the challenge, and have been very effective at protecting the local biological and cultural values.


CONTACT US

For information, email us at chiricahuaregionalcouncil@gmail.com.


Chiricahua Regional Council

PO Box 16480

Portal AZ 85632


CRC WEB SITE

WHO WE ARE

The Council is a citizens’ watchdog group that monitors public agency actions and other issues affecting the Chiricahua, Peloncillo and Dragoon Mountains and nearby areas of southeastern Arizona, southwestern New Mexico, and adjacent northern Mexico.

We protect valuable, intact habitats and champion the region’s natural and cultural integrity. Dark skies, open space, outstanding species diversity, corridors that link habitats, our ranching heritage––all of these values make our region what it is. Together, these treasures draw tens of thousands of visitors annually, all contributing to nature tourism, which underpins our regional economy.

The CRC promotes responsible land use and wise, science-informed stewardship of our unique natural heritage. Our broad constituency includes scientists, ranchers, birders, naturalists, astronomers, artists, residents, visitors, and many others, who value our region’s spectacular qualities.


A major strength of the organization lies in its broad constituency. Our membership includes biologists, ranchers, birders, residents, visitors, and other segments of the general public with a strong interest in the region’s well-being. 

___________________________________________________________









SUNDAY, DECEMBER 5, 2010

Coronado Forest Plan Under Major Criticism

by Noel Snyder


Every national forest operates under a forest plan that presents goals and actions to achieve goals.  These plans are periodically revised.  In March, the U.S. Forest Service released for public comment a Draft Forest Plan for future management of the Coronado National Forest.  This is a plan to replace the existing plan of 1986 and is expected to guide policies for the next 20 years.  Unfortunately, the new plan is limited largely to broad “feel-good” goals.  And because specific actions and their associated costs are mostly not presented, it isn’t possible to evaluate whether the goals are achievable, whether appropriate means will be employed to achieve goals, and how the Forest Service will resolve conflicts among goals.  In view of the major budgetary cuts the Forest Service has already experienced and can anticipate, it seems highly unlikely that adequate resources will exist to achieve many of the goals mentioned.  If adequate resources are not available which goals will be sacrificed?  In essence, the Forest Service seems to be asking the public to endorse its future actions without letting the public know what those actions may be.  

For those familiar with the detail of the 1986 Coronado plan, the newly released plan is astonishingly vague and leaves many matters only minimally addressed or simply unaddressed.  For example, missing from the plan is any discussion of border problems or how the the Forest Service is planning to address problems anticipated from climate change.  Areas of the Coronado close to the border have been under siege from illegal immigrants, who have trampled “highways” across the terrain, left mountains of trash, and repeatedly started major fires that have cost the taxpayer many millions of dollars.  Many of the trails on the Coronado are now effectively “owned” by well-armed drug smugglers, at least at night.  Yet the new plan says nothing about these problems and how they will be corrected.   If left uncorrected, these problems will undermine many other aspects of the plan.

Nevertheless, the aspect of the new plan that is by far the most troubling is the absence of any clear recognition of the overriding importance of what many observers maintain is the defining attribute of the Coronado – its tremendously high level of biodiversity.  This biodiversity is unmatched by any other national forest and has been honored nationally and internationally.  Protecting biodiversity is an overall national priority, and it is the Coronado’s outstanding biodiversity that supports a thriving ecotourism economy for many local communities.  Biodiversity is in fact the economic life blood of the region. This value should be featured in the plan as a central focus around which other goals need to be harmonized.  It is not.

Concerns over the Coronado’s biodiversity came into national focus in the 1990s when the Coronado Forest released a proposal to convert several of the Sky Island Units it administers into a National Recreation Area (NRA).  This was a proposal resulting not from public demand but from its potential to increase the Coronado’s budget. However, an NRA can only come to pass with public support and Congressional action.  In public meetings the proposal was blown away by vigorous and nearly unanimous opposition from people across the social and economic spectrum, who viewed conversion of the forest into a playground for mass recreation as a very bad idea.  What emerged instead was overwhelming public endorsement of low-impact quiet recreation on the forest consistent with maintaining the biological riches of the forest.  The NRA proposal was quietly dropped, but one wonders if anyone on the current planning staff of the Coronado remembers this embarrassing affair.  In the current draft plan, recreation development is mentioned 226 times while biodiversity is mentioned only 6 times.

To be fair, the Forest Service has belatedly announced it will be including a new Cave Creek Zoological and Botanical Area (ZBA) in its revisions to the draft plan, an area protecting a canyon with by far the highest density and diversity of nesting raptors known anywhere in the U.S.  But as welcome as the new ZBA is, the increased motorized recreation emphasis across the forest that is allowed in the new plan works directly against maintaining biodiversity values.  Under the existing forest plan, the Coronado already has far more roads than are permissible.  Biodiversity is not yet receiving the overall recognition and priority it deserves in the new plan.

In February the Forest Service expects to release a revised forest plan and a Draft Environmental Impact Statement on the plan.  It will be crucial for the public to respond with comments on these documents.